Day 216: Why I Scrapped Everything and Started Again.

Some weeks in this journey are about scaling up. This week was about tearing it all down and rebuilding from scratch — and being honest about why that had to happen.

- A Meta targeting glitch sent nearly half my ad spend to South Africa, an audience I don't sell into, at 36x the normal CPM cost.

- Three days with Meta support produced zero resolution, forcing a full campaign restart.

- I've gone all-in on a single new angle — the Myelin Method — with one campaign, one landing page, and a reset budget of £100/day.

- Early signs are cautiously positive, with cost per purchase beginning to fall and

Day 1 of the new campaign potentially turning a small profit.

What Actually Went Wrong

A few days ago, I duplicated an ad set to add some fresh creative because I'd noticed the cost per conversion was creeping up. That one action seemed to trigger something strange inside Meta's algorithm.

Sales started to plummet almost immediately. When I dug into the data, I discovered that nearly half of my ad budget was being directed at a South African audience — a market I've never intentionally targeted and don't sell into.

The CPM for that audience was approximately 36 times higher than my usual US targeting costs. It was bleeding the budget dry.

Three Days of Meta Support Going Nowhere

I spent three days going back and forth with Meta support trying to get this resolved. Unfortunately, that process produced absolutely nothing useful. No fix, no explanation, no resolution.

At that point, I had a decision to make: keep wrestling with a broken campaign or cut my losses and start fresh. Given that results had dwindled to virtually nothing, the answer was clear. It was time to go back to zero.

Introducing the Myelin Method Angle

Rather than just rebuilding the same campaign, I decided this was the right moment to fully commit to a new angle I'd been developing — the Myelin Method.

The concept is rooted in brain science: specifically, how myelin (the substance that coats neural pathways) is built through deliberate, repetitive practice.

The key insight for our audience is that your brain builds new skills at 70 the same way it does at 17.

Age isn't the barrier most people think it is. This maps directly onto the way Guitar Coach Magazine teaches — small, structured, step-by-step chunks.

The New Landing Page

We've built a brand new landing page centred entirely around this angle. The headline leads with the brain science hook and positions our teaching method as the practical application of that science.

The sales page itself is similar in many ways to what came before, but the entry point and framing are completely different. Instead of leading with muscle memory, we're leading with neuroscience.

It's a more compelling and credible hook — and one that speaks directly to the older beginner guitarist who worries it might be too late to learn.

One Campaign, One Message, One Focus

The strategic decision I've made with this restart is to go 100% in on a single message rather than split testing multiple angles simultaneously. Every ad in the campaign uses the Myelin Method copy.

The creatives vary — I've carried across a number of assets from the previous campaign — but the message is unified.

This focus means the budget is concentrated, the algorithm gets a clear signal, and I can actually evaluate whether this angle works without diluting the data across multiple variables.

Campaign Structure and Budget Reset

I've reset the budget right back to £100 per day — down from the £350–£400/day I was running previously. The campaign launched targeting the US and UK, and I've since added Nordic countries into the mix to help bring the CPM down.

Starting over means the campaign is back in Meta's learning phase, which always feels uncomfortable. But I've been nudging the budget upward over the past couple of days to try and accelerate through that phase and get into real optimisation territory sooner.

Performance Snapshot

The old campaign's final days were brutal. Cost per purchase went through the roof while strange CPM fluctuations made the data almost unreadable. The numbers were unsustainable and the campaign was actively losing money.

The new campaign is only a couple of days old, but here's where things stand:

- Cost per purchase: Still high but beginning to come down day-on-day

- CPM: Starting to decrease as the algorithm finds its footing

- Day 1 profit/loss: Potentially a small profit — the first positive sign in days

- Budget: Reset to £100/day, being scaled gradually

The Discipline of Leaving It Alone

One of the hardest things about being in the learning phase is resisting the urge to tinker. I'm checking in once a day and then stepping back. The campaign needs time and data to optimise — and every time I make a change, I risk resetting that process.

It's not easy when you're watching money go out every day. But making reactive changes based on two days of data is exactly how campaigns get broken — as this past week has demonstrated.

Looking Ahead: March Review on Tuesday

With April now underway and roughly five months left of this 12-month journey, Tuesday will bring a full review of March's performance. I'll be doing a deep dive into the numbers — and I won't be sugar-coating it. March was not a good month.

There's real money lost to account for and real lessons to extract from it.

But we're moving forward with a clearer strategy, a sharper angle, and a cleaner campaign structure. That counts for something.

Closing Reflection

Day 216 is a reminder that this journey isn't a straight line. Sometimes the most important move is admitting something isn't working and having the discipline to start again properly — not just patch it.

The Myelin Method angle feels right. The science is solid, the message is differentiated, and it connects directly to what we actually teach. Now we let it run and find out.

Resources & Next Steps

Free Top 10 Split-Tests: https://www.jonathanhowkins.com/split-testing

Join the Facebook community: https://www.facebook.com/groups/coursecreatorads

Subscribe on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@jonathanhowkins-coursecreator?sub_confirmation=1